top of page

Choice Challenge Activity: Rethink

Sep 14
5 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

Choice Challenge Activity: Rethink, 16-18 of 18, from My Teacher is Not an Octopus at AskMissPatience.com
Choice Challenge Activity: Rethink, 16-18 of 18, from My Teacher is Not an Octopus at AskMissPatience.com

Choice Challenge Activity: Rethink #12


Now that you have read My Teacher Is Not an Octopus, reviewed the Choice Challenge blogs, and tried the activities from the book — here is more practice.


Three activities per choice for the specific behavior. No timer. No one size fits all. Parents know their child(ren). Teachers know their students. Give each a try. Practice builds choice fitness.


When a child understands how to use the six choices, this leads to more fun. The choice becomes their own. The result is happier children, families, and classrooms.


These activities engage PILES. Physical, Intellectual, Language, Emotional, Social. They build teamwork. And they give a child the words to say, "I can do this."


The goal is not a timer. The goal is the choice becoming part of a child's internal dialogue. The words a child says to themselves when no one is watching.


The student will perform a desired better choice without being redirected or reminded.


Here are three ways to practice.


Activity 1: Rethink Spot


Goal: Make reflection safe and structured.


How to:


Sit in a spot chosen by the child.


Explain: "While in the Rethink Spot I will sit with you. You can talk about the rethink activity out loud or silently to yourself. I am here to support you either way."


Practice:


Think about two questions:


"What was my first choice?"

"What is my better choice?"


Stay with the child. No words needed. A calm presence is the whole point. If the child wants to talk, listen. If they do not, this is okay too. The spot is a safe space to process the questions.


Later, when a poor choice happens, guide the child to their rethink spot and use the same two questions.


Activity 2: "First Choice / Better Choice" Chart


Goal: Help children see the difference between old and new choices.


How to:


Draw two columns:


Label the columns in red for First Choice and green Better Choice.


The colors can help a child translate from the poor and better decision Choice Challenge board activities. Stop is read and Go is green is another way of looking at the activity.


Fill in examples together:


First Choice: "I yell." → Better Choice: "I use my words."

First Choice: "I grab." → Better Choice: "I wait my turn."


Keep the chart visible and add real examples over time.


Activity 3: Open Door Stories


Goal: Show that rethinking opens doors, not closes them.


How to:


Tell a short story:


"Joey shouted at a friend and lost a turn in the game."


Ask:


"What was Joey's first choice?"

"What better choice could Joey make next time?"

"How would that open the door to what Joey wanted?"


Connect it:


Our first choice can be an obstacle. Our better choice can be an open door.


Where did this choice begin?


When a poor choice keeps happening, review the six choices to find where the chain broke by asking the question -

Did we follow directions?

Did we use words?

Did we own the behavior?

Did we wait and take turns?

Did we breathe and calm?

Did we rethink?


The answer is usually the choice skipped. This is the one to practice next.


How the choices work together in this activity


Rethinking is where a poor choice becomes a better one. A child cannot rethink while in fight-or-flight. Breathe and Calm (#5) is a first step. The child needs to Rethink (#6) to name the first choice and the better option. Use Words (#2) is where the apology lives, if one is needed. And Wait and Take Turns (#4) is often the skill that, once practiced, creates patience assisting with the ability to problem solve using the six choices. Follow Directions (#1) and Own Behavior (#3) work hand in hand if the others are in operation, and the skills modeled.


These two are a combo pack of success.


Consider this example: Joey grabs a marker and yells.


Breathe and Calm (#5):

Joey sits in the Rethink Spot. Takes three bunny breaths.


Use Words (#2):

Theodore says: "Joey, I don't like when you grab my marker. It hurts my feelings."


Rethink (#6):

Joey says: "My first choice was grabbing the marker. My new better choice is asking first."


Own Behavior (#3):

Joey says: "Theodore, I apologize for grabbing the marker. This was not kind."


One moment. Four choices working together.


A simple takeaway


Questions to ask when rethinking:


"What was my first choice?"

"What is my better choice?"


Review:

What is the Choice Challenge? Blog and challenge blogs one through six for extended definitions from My Teacher Is Not an Octopus.


All six choices are a collaborative learning experience. They partner with each other on most occasions.

 

Children need consistent practice with this strategy before the skill becomes automatic.


Each child experiences social-emotional development at different speeds and levels. As a child uses the choices interacting with others, adjustments increase competency. The foundation through patience and practice builds behavior muscles.


Every time a child names their first choice and picks a new one without being prompted, the skill is building. Filling gaps or holes, as explained in the blog What is the Choice Challenge?" and the Choice Challenge Guide, is practice. Practice builds choice fitness.


Choice Challenge Guide will be released in eBook and paperback. You will have the option to download for free by signing up or buy online.


The choice is yours :)


About the author


Patience Filippo is a children's author, artist, educator, and veteran with decades of classroom experience. She created the Choice Challenge: Poor to Better Decisions for Everyday Behavior to help children and grown-ups be better humans, one better choice at a time. The Choice Challenge is the framework behind My Teacher Is Not an Octopus, a self-regulating behavior management book for early learners. Begin at birth. Grow into lifelong learning.


Motto: Empowering happiness through literacy.


Find Patience online https://linktr.ee/askmisspatience


©2026 Peace Road Publishing, LLC. Copying this publication for any commercial use is prohibited. This publication or any portion thereof may not be reproduced or used in any manner whatsoever without the express written permission of the publisher except for the use of brief quotations in a book review.


NO AI TRAINING OR DATA MINING: No part of this publication may be used, reproduced, scanned, ingested, or processed in any manner for the purpose of training, fine-tuning, or developing any artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), large language model (LLM), or generative AI technology, now known or hereafter devised. This prohibition expressly includes text and data mining (TDM), dataset inclusion, and algorithmic learning. All rights to use this work for AI training or development are expressly reserved and may only be exercised via a separate, written license agreement with the copyright holder. This work is expressly excluded from any text and data mining exceptions under applicable law. All rights reserved.


All rights to the text and final composite artwork are hereby assigned to Peace Road Publishing, LLC. The underlying illustrations are used with permission of the copyright owner. The final artwork integrates original illustrations using multi-layer technique incorporating watercolor and collage.

New York 

Cedar Rapids 

United States 

Made with ♥
for Learners Everywhere

AskMissPatience logo Patience Filippo

#AskMissPatience

Join the Author Info Team

  • Goodreads - black circle
  • Ask Miss Patience Youtube Channel
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X
  • TikTok
  • LinkedIn

Heads up: Posts may contain affiliate links. If you buy something through one of those links, you will not pay a penny more, but Peace Road Publishing will get a small commission, which helps keep the lights on and support us in promoting and donating to programs Empowering Happiness Through Literacy. Thank you!

bottom of page