top of page

Choice Challenge: Rethink

Sep 24
5 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

Choice Challenge: Rethink, 6 of 6 from My Teacher is Not an Octopus at AskMissPatience.com
Choice Challenge: Rethink, 6 of 6 from My Teacher is Not an Octopus at AskMissPatience.com

Choice Challenge: Rethink #6 (From Obstacle to Open Door)


Every child has had the "uh-oh" moment. The one where they already know what they did, and the next five seconds decide whether they learn from it or not.


Rethinking is how we turn that moment into a lesson instead of a lecture.


In the Choice Challenge rethink structure, invite children to name their first choice and their better choice, so mistakes become open doors instead of dead ends.


If the issue is a lack of awareness of an acceptable behavior, this can be modeled by replacing the previous decision with better options.


A choice is not poor until the guidelines have been discussed for young children and agreed upon within their knowledge and ability.


Even if parents model better choices, in the classroom, agreements need to be made at the beginning of the school year. And they need to be introduced to new students through the year.


If anyone arrives midyear, by then the class as a whole is all about teamwork. They can support the success of the new student. Because they all know, if they follow directions, they can have more fun!


A simple pattern is:


"My first choice was ___."

"My better choice is ___."


For example:


"My first choice was yelling. My better choice is using my words."

"My first choice was grabbing. My better choice is waiting my turn."

"My first choice was walking away. My better choice is staying and using my words."


Why this matters for behavior


Every time a behavior hole is open, the poor choice falls through it again. Rethinking is how we close the hole and hand the child the key to more options. They do not need us to fix it. They need us to ask, "What was the first choice that is not okay? What is the new option based on the challenge choices we have discussed?"


Sometimes a child needs encouragement and mentoring. They are stuck and are not certain what to decide now. This is where modeling can help.


The first step for the child is encouraging reflection. Then discussion on their discovery.


Their feedback determines what steps are followed from the adult to model of the six choices needed to resolve their challenge.


Development for each child is unique.


Although in groups it is common for the children to support each other. Teamwork is promoted and encouraged.


In a non-shaming environment the students with a grasp of the challenge concepts may encourage and share their understanding. This group affect can yield wonderful results. When the goal is universal amongst classmates.


The good news is that by this point the child has experience from the introduction of the Choice Challenge and may have options to share once rethinking has taken place.


How long rethinking takes is subjective. It is a solid idea to have a space the child already expressed is a place they can think about choices.


This is where they will sit while pondering the decision that led to this moment. And what the future agreement will be for how to act. There is no time limit as people process at different rates.


If they appear stuck, ask open-ended questions and host a conversation. Model ways to consider the options using the six choices available.


Rethinking is not a punishment.


This is a valuable resource for the habit of personal development. A time-out for the sake of punishment is not enough. The consequence of reflecting and rethinking is a joy. This offers growth and better relationships.


We are raising adults. The skills required for adulting are a lifelong learning process anyone can benefit from.


Rethinking is a better choice because it builds problem-solving skills, reduces shame, helps children see patterns in their behavior, and gives them ownership over their next step.


How the choices can work together


Rethinking is following directions. Words are used in the process and may include an apology as needed with dialogue between children or adult and child when they complete the rethink process. Breathe and Calm is helpful if the student, son or daughter is having a difficult time processing the moment.


A simple takeaway


Next time a child makes a poor choice try asking:

"What was your first choice?"

"What is your better choice?"

"How will this help you get what you want (or need)?"


Every time a child names their first choice and picks a new one without being prompted, a hole gets filled. Filling gaps or holes, as explained in the blog What is the Choice Challenge? and the Choice Challenge Guide, is practice. Practice builds choice fitness.

Rethinking turns "uh-oh" into "next time." It helps children see their choices as doors they can open, not walls they crash into.


Building walls keeps everyone out including those we need – Patience Filippo


Choice Challenge Guide will be released in eBook and paperback. You will have the option to download for free by signing up or buy online.


The choice is yours :)


About the author


Patience Filippo is a children's author, artist, educator, and veteran with decades of classroom experience. She created the Choice Challenge: Poor to Better Decisions for Everyday Behavior to help children and grown-ups be better humans, one better choice at a time. The Choice Challenge is the framework behind My Teacher Is Not an Octopus, a self-regulating behavior management book for early learners. Begin at birth. Grow into lifelong learning.


Motto: Empowering happiness through literacy.


Find Patience online https://linktr.ee/askmisspatience


Copyright © 2016, 2026 Patience Filippo / Illustrations © 2014 Jason Squadrito / Art and Design © 2026 Patience Filippo


©2026 Peace Road Publishing, LLC. Copying this publication for any commercial use is prohibited. This publication or any portion thereof may not be reproduced or used in any manner whatsoever without the express written permission of the publisher except for the use of brief quotations in a book review.


NO AI TRAINING OR DATA MINING: No part of this publication may be used, reproduced, scanned, ingested, or processed in any manner for the purpose of training, fine-tuning, or developing any artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), large language model (LLM), or generative AI technology, now known or hereafter devised. This prohibition expressly includes text and data mining (TDM), dataset inclusion, and algorithmic learning. All rights to use this work for AI training or development are expressly reserved and may only be exercised via a separate, written license agreement with the copyright holder. This work is expressly excluded from any text and data mining exceptions under applicable law. All rights reserved.


All rights to the text and final composite artwork are hereby assigned to Peace Road Publishing, LLC. The underlying illustrations are used with permission of the copyright owner. The final artwork integrates original illustrations using multi-layer technique incorporating watercolor and collage.

New York 

Cedar Rapids 

United States 

Made with ♥
for Learners Everywhere

AskMissPatience logo Patience Filippo

#AskMissPatience

Join the Author Info Team

  • Goodreads - black circle
  • Ask Miss Patience Youtube Channel
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X
  • TikTok
  • LinkedIn

Heads up: Posts may contain affiliate links. If you buy something through one of those links, you will not pay a penny more, but Peace Road Publishing will get a small commission, which helps keep the lights on and support us in promoting and donating to programs Empowering Happiness Through Literacy. Thank you!

bottom of page